Arizona has long been defined by fierce political independence, with its Republican leaders celebrated for their willingness to defy the party establishment. Figures like Barry Goldwater and John McCain epitomized this spirit rooted in intellectual rigor, principle over partisanship, and a commitment to the truth, even when inconvenient. Arizona Republicans were once known for their maverick nature, unafraid to challenge their opponents and their party when necessary. Today, however, Arizona’s GOP finds itself shifting away from that proud legacy, as candidates like Representative Andy Biggs represent a disturbing departure from the tradition of independent thought that defined the state’s politics for decades.
Biggs, currently running for governor, is emblematic of a broader transformation in the Arizona GOP, first crystallized by Kari Lake's rise. Lake’s embrace of Donald Trump’s divisive rhetoric, her rejection of the 2020 election results, and her inflammatory populism signaled a shift toward a more conformist, ideologically rigid party. Though Lake’s 2022 gubernatorial bid ultimately fell short, her brand of Trumpian politics left a lasting impact, paving the way for figures like Biggs to ascend to prominence. Biggs, in many ways, is the second coming of Lake. Bigg's candidacy has embraced the far-right elements of the GOP, trading independent thought and principle for loyalty to a discredited former president.
The departure from Arizona’s maverick tradition is not just a rhetorical shift but a profound transformation in how the state’s Republican Party sees itself. Where figures like Goldwater and McCain were known for their willingness to defy their party’s leadership when they felt it was in the country's best interest, Biggs is a product of a GOP that increasingly prizes party loyalty above all else. Biggs, in particular, has not only embraced Trump’s baseless claims about the 2020 election but has also fueled the narrative of election fraud. This stance is at odds with the fact-based, independent approach Goldwater and McCain would have championed.
Barry Goldwater’s brand of conservatism was defined by intellectual independence, a refusal to go along with the status quo simply because it was convenient or politically expedient. Goldwater believed in principles over party loyalty and had no qualms about challenging his party when he felt it was necessary. Whether it was his staunch opposition to the Vietnam War or his early warnings about government overreach, Goldwater was never afraid to stand alone, even when it cost him politically. John McCain, too, embodied this maverick spirit. Though a staunch conservative, McCain prioritized truth over politics, as seen in his famous 2017 vote against the Republican healthcare repeal, which defied party pressure. Their courage in standing up for their beliefs should inspire us all.
Biggs, on the other hand, represents the antithesis of this legacy. His loyalty to Trump and refusal to acknowledge the legitimacy of the 2020 election are not just political stances; they are emblematic of a broader trend within the Republican Party, where truth and principle have been subordinated to partisan loyalty. The Arizona GOP, once proud of its tradition of independent thought and dissent, now finds itself increasingly defined by conformity to a false narrative pushed by Trump and his allies.
What makes Biggs’s candidacy even more telling is his family's response. His brothers, William and Daniel Biggs, publicly denounced him for his role in perpetuating the false claims about the 2020 election. In an open letter, they went so far as to accuse Andy of being “at least partially responsible” for the January 6th Capitol riot. This family rift played out in public, highlighting a devastating truth: the shift toward Trumpism has torn apart not just the Republican Party but families and communities as well. The fact that Andy Biggs’s brothers have chosen to oppose him openly speaks volumes about the personal and political damage caused by this radical shift in the Arizona GOP. It's a cause for concern for all of us.
This public break within the Biggs family is significant because it underscores the moral and intellectual compromises that candidates like Biggs have made. For all their political disagreements, Barry Goldwater and John McCain were men of integrity who valued truth above all else. The reality is that no one who knows McCain personally had a poor thing to say about his character, let alone his family. Furthermore, neither would have ever bowled to false claims from a leader like Donald Trump, whose disdain for facts and truth is well-documented. Goldwater, who once defied the Republican Party on issues of war, would never have fallen in line with a demagogue whose claims of election fraud have been thoroughly debunked. McCain, a man who fought for what was right even when it cost him politically, would have rejected the division and lies that have defined much of Trump’s tenure in office.
Despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, Biggs’s willingness to perpetuate these false claims represents a betrayal of the principles that Goldwater and McCain held dear. It marks a shift from a party defined by intellectual independence to one characterized by loyalty to a man who prioritizes personal power over truth or democracy. This betrayal should leave us all feeling deeply disappointed.
The fracturing of the Biggs family also highlights a more significant cultural divide within Arizona’s Republican Party. Once a party that prided itself on its independent streak and commitment to doing what was right, Arizona Republicans are now increasingly divided over whether loyalty to Trump should outweigh loyalty to truth and principle. The Arizona GOP, once a bastion of maverick independence, is increasingly shaped by the ideological rigidity and culture of grievance fostered by Trump’s influence.
The rise of Biggs and the transformation of Arizona’s Republican Party marks a significant departure from the state’s political history. Once home to leaders who championed independent thought and principled conservatism, Arizona now finds itself increasingly defined by the politics of division, loyalty to a false narrative, and a willingness to sacrifice truth for political gain. The question for Arizona voters is whether they will continue to embrace this shift or fight to reclaim the legacy of Goldwater and McCain: this legacy valued principle, independence, and the courage to stand alone when necessary.
The Biggs family’s public opposition to Andy is not just a political disagreement; it reflects the profound moral and ideological rift created within the Arizona GOP. The state’s Republican Party is no longer the party of Goldwater and McCain. It is a party that has chosen loyalty to Trump and his divisive politics over the truth. Arizona’s political future hinges on whether voters will continue to support candidates like Biggs or demand a return to the values of independence and integrity that once defined the state’s political character. The time has come for Arizona Republicans to ask themselves: what kind of party do they want to be, and will they continue to allow the spirit of the maverick to slip further away?
Add comment
Comments