It all begins with the unmistakable squeak of sneakers on polished gym floors and the thud of a rubber ball striking the wall. Whether it was a Tuesday morning, just after lunch, or the last period before the final bell, in a suburban middle school in Ohio, a cramped urban gym in New York City, or an outdoor blacktop in Los Angeles, dodgeball was a part of your childhood if you grew up in America. It wasn't just a passing trend or something you saw on television, but a lived experience. It was there, wedged between laps around the track and climbing the rope in physical education class. It was part of the rhythm of youth, a common denominator that cut across geography, race, and class. Yet for all its ubiquity and cultural weight in our collective memory, dodgeball never became what so many other American games became. It never matured. It was never institutionalized. It never developed into a sport that one could grow up to play professionally, pack stadiums, and be televised on a Sunday afternoon. It was everywhere, and yet it went nowhere. That paradox lies at the heart of dodgeball’s strange and forgotten history. Yet, thoughts of the game evoke a sense of nostalgia for the readers of this article, highlighting its cultural significance and clearly demonstrating it still holds a place in our collective memory as a society.